Johannesburg's South Gauteng High Court has dismissed an appeal by jeweller David Graziani, confirming that he must pay Angie Spindler R89,640 after swapping her family heirloom diamond for a brown stone of far lesser value while it was in his possession in 2019.
Acting Judges JW Roos and N Mzuzu found that the most probable inference from the evidence was that Graziani substituted the diamond himself, pointing to his exclusive control of the stone, his repeated lies about its whereabouts, and his own admission that he deceived his client. The judgment, reported by IOL, was delivered after Graziani challenged a magistrate's earlier ruling in Spindler's favour.
How a family heirloom became a brown stone
Spindler owned a solitaire diamond passed down through her family. In 2006, Graziani, a jeweller and diamond mounter, removed the stone from its gold setting and mounted it in a platinum ring. His certificate at the time described a 1.04-carat diamond with colour H and clarity VVS1, a genuinely high-grade stone.
In 2015, he issued a second certificate, this time describing a 0.987-carat diamond with colour F and clarity VS1, and valued the ring at R135,939.79. The discrepancies between the two certificates already raised questions, but the real betrayal came later.
On February 19, 2019, Spindler handed the ring to Graziani with clear instructions: remove the stone, send it to the European Gemological Laboratory for certification, and buy the platinum setting. The stone stayed in his possession until March 4, 2019, when it finally reached the laboratory.
The EGL report came back with devastating figures. The diamond weighed 0.926 carats, colour L, brown, with clarity SI1. Spindler immediately disputed that it was her diamond.
The jeweller who admitted lying to his client
What makes this case damning is Graziani's own testimony. The court heard that between February 19 and March 4, 2019, he told Spindler the diamond was already at the laboratory when it was still sitting in his safe.
On February 28, he went further and told her the stone's colour had changed and that it was of a much lower grade, even though the laboratory had not yet examined it. During cross-examination, he admitted he had lied about the colour changing to buy himself time.
He also conceded that he had lied about how he calculated the 2015 valuation, and that most of his WhatsApp messages to Spindler were untruthful. He kept no job card, no paper trail, and no video footage relating to the diamond.
The judges seized on the February 28 statement as the decisive piece of evidence.
